Title: Are We Truly Walking With God, or Are We Only Talking About Him?

Bradcatania

Member
I would love to start a meaningful Bible study discussion with everyone here.


Sometimes, we become so occupied with attending church, quoting Scriptures, and talking about our faith that we forget to examine our actual relationship with God.


Jesus said in Matthew 7:21:


“Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ will enter the kingdom of heaven, but only the one who does the will of my Father who is in heaven.”


This raises an important question:


How do we know that we are truly growing spiritually and not simply becoming familiar with religious activities?


A few questions I’d love us to reflect on:


  1. Can someone know the Bible very well but still be far from God?
  2. How do we maintain our faith when prayers seem unanswered?
  3. Is obedience to God more important than simply knowing Scripture?
  4. What is one Bible verse that completely changed the way you live?

I believe Bible study should go beyond reading words. It should transform our hearts, our decisions, our character, and how we treat other people.


Let’s share our thoughts respectfully, learn from one another, and grow together in Christ.


May our lives reflect the Word we profess. God bless everyone. ❤️
 
  1. Can someone know the Bible very well but still be far from God?
  2. How do we maintain our faith when prayers seem unanswered?
  3. Is obedience to God more important than simply knowing Scripture?
  4. What is one Bible verse that completely changed the way you live?

God thoughts to consider.

1. No.

To properly grasp scripture you have to know God / be close to Him and have the Holy Spirit leading you. In order to grasp many truths in Scripture, it requires a level of A. interest, B. honesty, and C. Spirit-led guidance that we, in our flesh, simply do not have.

When you 'fall in love' with your Creator because you read that He is good (Psalm 136:1), loving and righteous in all His ways (Psalm 145:17), you may develop a tremendous interest in studying the Bible. However, you will still need the Holy Spirit to help you grasp the context and the message behind the words you are reading.

Many think they know Scripture well, and we too may 'think' they do. There are very simple 'acid tests' that reveal they don't.

2. Two spaces for comment.

A. Non-Christians who think they are Christians.

They mostly see God at work from afar and assume Him answering another's prayer is their answer, when it is really only an overlap. Unless we are Christians or in the process of becoming one, God's hands are completely tied from helping us John 9:31. IE there is no God given Rom 12:3 faith to maintain as there was never any real James 4:8 (stop doing evil), Psalm 51:17 (true repentance), James 1:27 (true servitude) or Rev 2:10 (martyrdom) type pursuit toward God.

B. Christians who know they are Christians per 2 Cor 13:5 and Rom 10:9.

Saving faith to believe Jesus is Lord and was raised from the dead is only gifted to those who pass God's judgement of heart and mind. For this a person needs a 'real' encounter with God per 1 Cor 12:3 and Matt 16:16-17.

These 'real' Christians do not care if God does or does not answer prayers. They understand the wisdom from God in a statement like 'my grace is sufficient for you' 2 Cor 12:9.

Continuing to trust God when the answer is not what we hoped for, or when no answer comes, is a particularly clear demonstration of faith.

3.
The two go hand in hand. If love God you will want to obey His commandments and read more and more about Him.

4. Psalm 145:17 The Lord is righteous in all his ways, and holy in all his works

When I first properly grasped that God is truly righteous in all His ways, my love and respect for Him increased to the maximum. Even more so then grasping His love. As, what is love if it can be 'partial'. But when you grasp that He is righteous and therefore perfectly impartial, well now His love hits harder.

Most atheists (disgruntled ex Christians) and people in differing religions have this idea of a God that is evil or a mix of good and evil. This is why they feel justified in mocking Him and or not properly serving Him. But were they too properly grasp that He is only good. As good as He is great. Well, that is life changing.

Example:

Lie = My child dies. God took him before he had a chance to grow up. God is evil. Let me now spend 2 hours a day mocking God on atheist forums and telling everyone around me that God does not exist and, if He does, who should care about serving Him? Christians are all 'suck-ups'.

Truth = My child dies. God, who completely and utterly hates what is evil, allows space for it to take place in His universe because He wants us, His highly intelligent creations (Hebrews 2:7), to have true free will. Children go straight to heaven (2 Samuel 12:22-23), to be tested by the devil another day (Rev 20:3). God truly loves children and each one of us. Imagine a world with no true free will.
 
we forget to examine our actual relationship with God.
Welcome brother. Like relationships with people, spending quality time with God and His word deepens the bond.

Bible study should go beyond reading words. It should transform our hearts, our decisions, our character, and how we treat other people.
I've been on many christian forums over the years and how we treat each other is ironically often not reflective of Christ. This site is one of the best in that regard.

I've been sick/disabled since Obama was the brand new president so my favorite verse is: 2 Corinthians 12:9

We tend to over complicate things. A humble heartfelt thank you is a great prayer as God knows your heart.

 
  1. Can someone know the Bible very well but still be far from God?
  2. How do we maintain our faith when prayers seem unanswered?
  3. Is obedience to God more important than simply knowing Scripture?
  4. What is one Bible verse that completely changed the way you live?
Good morning Brad!
#0) My dossier: Former cultist turned Protestant currently in his sixth OCIA (Roman Catholic flavored Christian newbie) class later today. Mark 9:38-41

1) Yes, but only humans have a lifetime to repent, and Jesus who is Truth hears His sheep. James 2:19

2) By maintaining thankful prayers. For me, the current Church I attend provides a lot of helps throughout the day, so one can effectively "pray without ceasing". 1 Thessalonians 5:16-18

3) Yes. Thank God the Holy Bible is full of examples of men and women and children who persevered in doing good despite the odds. And they didn't have eidetic nor computerized memory of scripture then.

4) James 1:5-6 ... And this one is like it, Isaiah 59:1-2 (written 538 BC or so). If you pray, you know your own voice, so we must expect Our Holy, Holy, Holy Father in Heaven to answer in a personal way.
 
John 14:21 He who has My commandments and keeps them, it is he who loves Me. And he who loves Me will be loved by My Father, and I will love him and manifest Myself to him."
 
How do we know that we are truly growing spiritually and not simply becoming familiar with religious activities?

Such a rich and good question, I would say examine your thoughts. Are you constantly thanking God, praising God, praying to God. Just how grateful am I to God. Do you look forward to church, reading the word. Do you get excited being around other strong believers and talking about God. This last one I find more and more of a litmus test, I am the point I do not like being around people who are not sold out for Christ. I have friends that claim to be believers but when you bring up God they change the subject rather quickly and I can tell they just are not that interested. The majority of my friends are sold out for Christ and I love being around them speaking about God and serving him. Serving God is another good indicator, does it fill your spirit do you get much joy out of it, or is more of a obligation?
  1. Can someone know the Bible very well but still be far from God?
  2. How do we maintain our faith when prayers seem unanswered?
  3. Is obedience to God more important than simply knowing Scripture?
  4. What is one Bible verse that completely changed the way you live?
1. off course the pharisees are a prime example

2. Faith is Faith circumstances should not deter a person faith, but what does the bible say faith comes from the word of God, so in order to maintain faith you must be in the word of God you must eat you spiritual food.

Romans 10:17​

So faith comes from hearing, and hearing through the word of Christ.

3. Well you have to know scripture first to be obedient to God, for example I grew up in the catholic church and never new sex outside of marriage was a sin until I was about 35 and started reading the bible.

4. This verse scared me to death, as I was guilty of all of them, and practicing some of them, talk about conviction ! This is what I call a healthy fear of God doing what it is supposed to do,

1 Corinthians 6:9-10​

Or do you not know that the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived: neither the sexually immoral, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor men who practice homosexuality, nor thieves, nor the greedy, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor swindlers will inherit the kingdom of God.
 
2Co 13:5 Examine yourselves as to whether you are in the faith. Test yourselves. Do you not know yourselves, that Jesus Christ is in you?—unless indeed you are disqualified. (KJV)

2Co 13:5 Examine and test and evaluate your own selves to see whether you are holding to your faith and showing the proper fruits of it. Test and prove yourselves [N1not Christ]. Do you not yourselves realize and know [thoroughly by an ever-increasing experience] that Jesus Christ is in you--unless you are [counterfeits] disapproved on trial and rejected? (AMP)
 
Can someone know the Bible very well but still be far from God?
Absolutely. It is possible to be intimately acquainted with the Bible, but refuse its message. When Jesus addressed these men, He said "And ye will not come to me, that ye might have life" (John 5:40). They knew the Bible and could find references leading them to Jesus, yet chose not to. Do we allow God's Word to convict us, or only use it to convict others?

How do we maintain our faith when prayers seem unanswered?
We continue to pray and rely on God, without knowing why. As stated in 1 John 5: 14, "If we ask any thing according to his will, he heareth us." Of course, that doesn't guarantee that we'll receive what we pray for, nor at the time that we desire! Nor will we discover all the answers as to why God may have delayed in answering. However, we shouldn't allow our lack of understanding to lead us away from God's explicit instructions.

Is obedience to God more important than simply knowing Scripture?
Yes. "But be ye doers of the word, and not hearers only, deceiving your own selves" (James 1:22). However, there is a connection between knowing the Bible and acting on it. If we refuse to hear and accept God's message to us, how can we possibly follow His commands? While we are not to try and earn our salvation, we must demonstrate the fruit of our faith (Ephesians 2:8-10).

What is one Bible verse that completely changed the way you live?
I think that 1 John 3: 18 "My little children, let us not love in word, neither in tongue; but in deed and in truth" is a great example. Anyone can claim to love another. But how will we respond when they require something of us? The preceding verses describe turning away from a needy 'brother'. This forces us to consider how we respond to the people around us.
 
Mat 15:7 Hypocrites! Well did Isaiah prophesy about you, saying:
Mat 15:8 'THESE PEOPLE DRAW NEAR TO ME WITH THEIR MOUTH, AND HONOR ME WITH THEIR LIPS, BUT THEIR HEART IS FAR FROM ME.
Mat 15:9 AND IN VAIN THEY WORSHIP ME, TEACHING AS DOCTRINES THE COMMANDMENTS OF MEN.' "
 
These 'real' Christians do not care if God does or does not answer prayers. They understand the wisdom from God in a statement like 'my grace is sufficient for you' 2 Cor 12:9.
this is an unrighteous perspective.


A real christian is in communion with the Father and does not ask for anything that is impossible, and also asks in faith without doubting as James describes in chapter 1.

If anyone does not care if God answers their prayers, then by definition those prayers will not be answered. You will probably demand "where is that in the bible" and i would ask you, where isn't it in the bible? go look at the intercessions of righteous men who changed the course of entire nations. can you in good faith say they didn't care?
Moses holds his own salvation as a ransom when he tells God "or blot my name out of your book!"

your quote of Paul's specific circumstances regards his spiritual harassment problem regarding his own conceitedness, which he did not repent from, otherwise the demon would have departed from him.
By reason of the exceeding greatness of the revelations, that I should not be exalted excessively, a thorn in the flesh was given to me: a messenger of Satan to torment me, that I should not be exalted excessively. 8Concerning this thing, I begged the Lord three times that it might depart from me.

Faith is not perfected in weakness. it is perfected in maturity. you can argue weakness is the flesh decaying and faith is perfected as we resist the desires of the flesh as the body dies and our spirits seek spiritual maturity as they learn through 70 years of suffering that the flesh is useless. sure, i don't have a real problem with that. but to think faith is perfected in persistence in spiritual weakness and immaturity is not biblical. Seek Wisdom and Spiritual Meat!

but to think that we are just pawns wandering around expected to believe God is good and toss our prayers into a roulette wheel to see if God will answer them without our authentic spiritual care and involvement in those prayers/desires, is antichrist.
 
Last edited:
  1. Can someone know the Bible very well but still be far from God?
  2. How do we maintain our faith when prayers seem unanswered?
  3. Is obedience to God more important than simply knowing Scripture?
  4. What is one Bible verse that completely changed the way you live?
(1) yes i would give you this: Meru Foundation Research: Hebrew Alphabet, Genesis, Geometric Metaphor, and Kabbalah 40 years of study, and he's still an atheist, but believes the book of Genesis is the most complex human creation in all of human history.

(2) is a distraction. ask for wisdom and discernment and God will show you why your prayers are or are not answered. 13 years ago i asked God to return my ex wife to me. today, i think she is my half sister and 3+ families conspired together to cover up certain matters in 1994 in part by lying to her and telling her that her dad died before she was born. so when she found me again 18 years later, it was not sin (except for the fact she was still legally married to a man who divorced her 6 months after we met) but i still have authority over her, to this day. So if you want impossible, 30+ year long spiritual weirdness, I've experienced it, and also helped a few other people escape their own similar problems.

(3) yes of course, you almost don't even need to read the bible. you need to do whatever God puts on your heart to do, and as you mature that becomes less and less as you "know what to do" and are expected to continue the work on your own*. This is at every level of personal development. For example back in 2016 one of my guardian angels brought to my mind a number of times it protected me and it told me "i will be leaving you soon" and my first thought was: "OH Good I am All Grown Up Now!" yes, really, that happened as i was cooking breakfast at my parents house when i should have been gainfully employed and married 5 years prior! i told a woman this story and she replied with "i would be devastated if my guardian angel told me it would leave me."

About a year ago i had a pretty simple dream, a warning to follow my own intuition. Since that dream and some other warnings and experiences, I have since concluded that certain kinds of premonitions and gut feelings happen when "you" become aware of what another person is tempted with. Meaning: the information is not from God, but you are still expected to take the higher road and take reasonable measures to prevent the person who is tempted, from sinning. this can be as simple as you're driving on a high way and have some "unnatural concerns" and so you back off from your usual following distance and sure enough there's a traffic jam up ahead 5 minutes later and you may, or may not have, prevented an accident by doing so. This sort of thing happens to me all the time. and not just on the road. i skipped going to church for the last month to put some distance between myself and someone i was warned about in a dream. -my wife also had the same warning, as well as a third person but he received it as nonspecific: "something is wrong"

(4) "now is the judgement, now shall the ruler of the world be cast out"
-it destroys so many end times eschatology arguments. the fight is now. get to it.

*to clarify on this, 14 years ago i heard a number of good teachings by some men that are still in pastoral offices today. the spiritual anointing you can be given to do public or non public works is separate from your own personal spiritual development. one of the mechanisms by which pastors decay and fail is when their personal development lags behind their congregations and they end up preaching their own convictions of sin, and not the prophetic conviction of sins their congregations need to hear. This extends well beyond mere conviction of sin, and into the 5 fold ministry at every level. -i have learned this by experience with regard to a few people i have been given to pray for in prophetic power. --I had to first overcome my own sins before i could pray for them in effective power.
 
Last edited:
this is an unrighteous perspective.

Why is my line unrighteous? Your explanation after this statement doesn't answer this accusation.

A real christian is in communion with the Father and does not ask for anything that is impossible,

Why? Most prayer requests are requests for miracles.

and also asks in faith without doubting as James describes in chapter 1.

Please quote James, I don't think you think Christian faith is what it is. You are alluding to us being positive, like a child is in Santa Claus. That is not Christian faith.

If anyone does not care if God answers their prayers, then by definition those prayers will not be answered.

By definition? You make a problem known to your Father and He reacts / answers as He chooses to.

Our ability to be positive or negative is completely and utterly irrelevant to us being His child. A sinner for example can be as positive / full of self mustered faith as is humanly possible and God will still NOT answer their prayers John 9:31.

You will probably demand "where is that in the bible"

Yes, correct. I don't see a single actual scripture in your post.

Don't mention James 1, type / quote the actual verses that make your case.

and i would ask you, where isn't it in the bible? go look at the intercessions of righteous men who changed the course of entire nations. can you in good faith say they didn't care?

'Righteous men changed the course of entire nations because they cared about God answering their prayers'? Is that your point? I am battling to grasp your meaning here.

If that's the case, where is the glory of God? and why does the Lord's prayer say ''thy will be done'' and Jesus states before the cross ''thy will be done''. Sometimes we can think something is good but God can disagree.

Do you think a wise person trusts God or forces His hand? That is the focus of the argument. Please try stay on that point.

Moses holds his own salvation as a ransom when he tells God "or blot my name out of your book!"

It is Moses reasoning with God. God invites us all to do this. That line has nothing to do with forcing God's hand in a prayer request.

your quote of Paul's specific circumstances regards his spiritual harassment problem regarding his own conceitedness, which he did not repent from, otherwise the demon would have departed from him. By reason of the exceeding greatness of the revelations, that I should not be exalted excessively, a thorn in the flesh was given to me: a messenger of Satan to torment me, that I should not be exalted excessively. 8Concerning this thing, I begged the Lord three times that it might depart from me.

Not sure what you are on about. Please use the quote function if you say I said something.

You believe Paul's thorn was a demon? Do you have scripture for that?

Note that Paul begged God to remove it and God did not. Do you think Paul lacked faith?


Faith is not perfected in weakness.

If by weakness you mean suffering. It most certainly is.

Look at a marriage. Ask your spouse to spend a week travelling with a well known male rockstar and their band. If she remains faithful through it all, wow what a wife!

it is perfected in maturity. you can argue weakness is the flesh decaying and faith is perfected as we resist the desires of the flesh as the body dies and our spirits seek spiritual maturity as they learn through 70 years of suffering that the flesh is useless. sure, i don't have a real problem with that. but to think faith is perfected in persistence in spiritual weakness and immaturity is not biblical. Seek Wisdom and Spiritual Meat!

I don't follow entirely. Growing in Faith is 'live'. For a Christian you can just as easily say 'trusting God' and not 'living by faith'.

Trusting God is a day to day thing just as fearing Him is. Sure, I agree that we can be mature and have a high level of trust from trusting Him for many years and or just believing what scripture teaches us.

We need to be careful though. Having more trust in God has absultely nothing to do with having more ''faith''. We have more faith ''IN God''. Not 'more faith'. Faith is not a currency with prayer. By using the word ''faith'' over and over, you make it seem as though ''faith'' alone is of something of value to God. Which is insanity really. Example, imagine thinking that something like your ability to believe in pink unicorns (faith = belief in the unseen) carries weight with God.

but to think that we are just pawns wandering around expected to believe God is good and toss our prayers into a roulette wheel to see if God will answer them without our authentic spiritual care and involvement in those prayers/desires, is antichrist.

I don't think you are properly grasping my belief.

God answers all the prayers of Christians. Scripture states that only sinners do not have their prayers answered John 9:31.

The discussion is around us approving of God's answers. Sometimes the answer is a No. No, I will not heal you. And no amount of ''positivity'' will change that answer.
 
If by weakness you mean suffering. It most certainly is.

Look at a marriage. Ask your spouse to spend a week travelling with a well known male rockstar and their band. If she remains faithful through it all, wow what a wife!
I did not use the word suffering nor did paul.

You can try to save his theology by changing the meanings of words if you want. But Where did Jesus say suffering was necessary?

And as for my wife you do not know her.
 
A messenger from satan

You have quoted 2 Corinthians 12:7, but that doesn't establish that Paul's thorn was a demon. A messenger of Satan is not necessarily a literal demonic being inhabiting or tormenting Paul.

There is considerable scholarly support for the view that Paul's thorn was a physical affliction, with blindness or an eye condition being among the leading interpretations.

Consider Galatians 4:13-15 and 6:11, where Paul refers to his physical weakness and the possibility that the Galatians would have given him their own eyes. Also consider Acts 9:8-9, where Paul was temporarily blinded.

So where is your actual scriptural evidence that the thorn was a demon? Quoting the phrase "messenger of Satan" simply repeats the description. It doesn't prove your interpretation of what the thorn was.
 
Absolutely not

Not that simple

I did not use the word suffering nor did paul.

You can try to save his theology by changing the meanings of words if you want. But Where did Jesus say suffering was necessary?

And as for my wife you do not know her.

Going forward, if you cannot support your claims with Scripture, don't expect a reply from me. You're turning a good Christian discussion forum into a preschool playground. I'm here to discuss Scripture, not entertain childish assertions.
 
Back
Top