Welcome!

By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our community.

SignUp Now!
  • Welcome to Talk Jesus Christian Forums

    Celebrating 20 Years!

    A bible based, Jesus Christ centered community.

    Register Log In

Charlie Kirk

The question is what does it mean to provide, how much do we need ourselves before we decide to help others, and i say need, not want, when there are 1 billion men, women and children living in abject poverty on less than a couple of $ a day, when around 15,000 children die every day from malnutrition and disease, when the Christ we profess to follow says that we should "Deny ourselves, take up our cross and follow him" and that in the face of the hungry, the homeless, the sick, the thir5sty and imprisoned we see him, then how much will it take to sayisfy our "providing" before we deem to help him?.

In this world of vast resources it shouldnt be a question of "us or them", we are ALL Gods children and we ALL deserve to be treated with Love and compassion no matter where we are born, there are enough resources to provide everyone with a decent life its only through the greed and selfishness of those who want to "provide" more than their fair share that Hunger, Poverty, suffering and Death consume so many.

Well if thats the case then the Love of God is surely not within them, God has provided enough for all, its only our sin that makes this world the Hell that it is for so many.

Could i ask you a question, you accused me of "spreading lies about Charlie Kirk", i'd be interested to know what i said to make you believe this?.

And you also accused me of "Not wanting to do the leg work" in finding out about CK, i think you misunderstand the nature of a discussion board, i make a statement, you say why you agree or why you dont agree with what ive said and we "discuss" until we come to an understanding of the others position, thats what makes this discussion board so important, for it brings people of differing views together who can talk, hopefully without rancour, and get to understand differing views of what it means to be a Follower of Christ.
What does it mean to provide?? Oh my.. please spend time with the Lord and allow Him to guide your ways..Just Be still n know He is God and wait patiently for the Lord to answer

I waited patiently for the Lord; and he inclined unto me, and heard my cry.

He brought me up also out of an horrible pit, out of the miry clay, and set my feet upon a rock, and established my goings.

And he hath put a new song in my mouth, even praise unto our God: many shall see it, and fear, and shall trust in the Lord.

Blessed is that man that maketh the Lord his trust, and respecteth not the proud, nor such as turn aside to lies.

(⁠っ⁠.⁠❛⁠ ⁠ᴗ⁠ ⁠❛⁠.⁠)⁠っ
 
No. There were many stoned to death that did repent. It is common knowledge that an opportunity is always given. Even Muslims practice this today.

I am going to try a different angle. You and I cannot properly judge depths of hearts and minds. Only God can Jer 17:9-11. Before Jesus, 'Gods people (aka Jews at the time)' would therefore not attempt to play God. They would see a mortal sin and pass sentence. But with Jesus, the cross and the now very present Holy Spirit, things have changed. We can know that someone who becomes a Christian can truly have a changed heart and mind. Making it crystal clear that stoning any Christian guilty of a mortal sin to death, be an utter and complete waste of a life that can and will truly serve God. At the same time we can conclude that all living have an opportunity to truly repent of their sins and be made new creations in Christ. It is therefore not prudent for God to enforce the death penalty on anyone.
Agreed, I have seen many testimonies of prisoners waiting decades on death row who have undergone a miraculous change in their lives, they have replaced the hate and anger they once felt with a heart of compassion, even finding Christ in their hour of need, so much so that even relatives of those they murdered have called for their death sentence to be reprieved, none of us can truly know the hearts and minds of those around us or what motivates others to do what they do, we are ALL sinners, ALL in need of gods mercy and forgiveness and NONE of us are in a position to judge and condemn others , that is Gods prerogative alone.
This is true at large, but there are three exceptions that I see in the NT.

1. Stopping the work of God

Many say Ananias and Saphira died because they lied to the Peter. Whilst that was their sin, a deeper investigation shows that by withholding their true fortune from God, they were stifling God's plans for the early church. This resulted in their instant death.
But how do you know someone is "Stopping the work of God", despots and Charlatans throughout history have commanded that they are doing Gods work and that anyone that opposes them are opposing Gods will and are servants of the Devil, even the Nazis had "Gott mit Uns" on the belt buckles of their uniforms and Hitler wrote in Mein Kampf that in persecuting the Jews he was doing "the will of the Creator" and in the US today there are those that see Donald Trump as an instrument of God and any that oppose him as doing the work of the Devil.. So how would you know who is and who isnt "Stopping the work of God"?,
2. Betraying Jesus

Judas may have killed himself, but did God try stop him?
Again the question is who decides who is and who isnt "betraying jesus", as you rightly say we cant see into someones heart and soul, by definition ALL Christians believe they are following Christ in the way he wants them to, but given so many divergent views on what constitutes discipleship they cant all be right, so some are betraying Jesus, but who decides who they are, you, me, miserable sinners procalaiming who is the betrayer and who is true, i dont think so, leave that to God, who knows ALL and whose Judgement is righteous and just.
3. To uphold God given laws that are required to properly govern a society.

As explained very clearly by Paul in Romans 13:1–4, "Let every person be subject to the governing authorities… for he [the authority] is God’s servant for your good. But if you do wrong, be afraid, for he does not bear the sword in vain. He is the servant of God, an avenger who carries out God’s wrath on the wrongdoer.” and Acts 25:11 “If then I am a wrongdoer and have committed anything for which I deserve to die, I do not seek to escape death''. We see from the words of Jesus that these laws are influenced from above John 19:11 You would have no authority over me at all unless it had been given you
again, who decides what it means to "uphold God given laws that are required to properly govern a society", we have Christians from all sections of the political spectrum whose views on what constitutes "proper governance" differ widely, some see the cutting of provision for those in need, the massive spending on weapons and the military, the persecution of the "stranger" and the further enriching of the wealthy as "proper Governance", but is that what Christ commands, i think not, so to uphold a death sentence on those we deem "opposing Gods given laws that properly govern a society" would lead to a persecution reminiscent of the worst totalitarian regimes, Pinochet considered himself a Christian upholding Gods Laws in Chile by opposing Socialism and under his regime thousands were arrested, tortured and murdered, the same happened in Guatemala under Rios Montt in the 1980's when thousands of indigenous men, women and children were murdered in an attempt to destroy what the ruling military dictatorship held to be a threat to both Gods laws and the State. You are playing with fire, and when that happens ,people get burnt.
Now, the death penalty for Charlie Kirks murder definitely falls into point 3. You don't need the death penalty for all murderers. But you do need it for a murderer that can start a chain reaction of murders and have a massive negative impact on society.
And who decides what murders have a "massive negative impact on Society", would you call for the killer of the 2 democrat legislators a few months before CK 's murder to be put to death, and what of someone who slashes Overseas Aid causing the deaths of millions of the poorest men, women and children, should they be put to death for the "massive negative impact on their societies", or what of the arms sellers , bothy in the US and abroad, what of the Arms companies and the Politicians that supported them who sold Billions of $'s of weapons to Israel at the height of the genocide in Gaza where that society wasnt just massivrly negatively impacted", but totally destroyed, should they be put to death, and what of the Oil, Coal and Gas corporations that have sold their products throughout the world knowing full well the "massive negative impact" it would have on societies, what punishment for them, or the Drug companies, who through their policy of high pricing ,price essential drugs out of the reach of poor people leading to rampant disease and illnes that costs the lives of millions every year and untold suffering, and on, and on and on......, we live in a sinful world, a world driven by greed, selfishness, envy, hate and lust , a world that cares little for the suffering of others, a world where the Devil could offer Christ all of the Governments, because as he said, " All this power i will give to you, for it is delivered to me and to whomsoever i choose to give it to". We are A:LL sinners in a sinful world and NONE of us are so free of that sin that we can cast the first stone".
That is logical and a 'duh' judgement. Paul would rebuke Christians who could not judge matters better than the unsaved 1 Cor 6:1-9.
 
The Truth is just the Truth what is to discuss..? If the Truth is right or wrong?..
Remember what I wrote to you about long post with me??how I get lost with mans words?..
The Truth is very simple He is very easy to understand He is not like man who don't say what He don't mean..
I was brought up N. Philadelphia.. I watched what happened there with my own eyes . I seen what man is capable of the great evils.. I've seen "church" after "church" all denominations exchange hands from leader to leader I watch them scramble to get that cash to claim to send missionaries to other countries while the children in their neighborhood at they age of five are on street corners yelling boomba to signal the drug and gun dealers that the police are coming..I've seen the dead lye on the ground uncovered for hrs upon hrs shot up because the police n fire and ambulance people don't want to deal with the hood... I've had little children that were neighbors that were raped tortured n left for dead at the ages of three and up..

There is a way which seemeth right unto a man, but the end thereof are the ways of death

There's only one Truth man likes to force his will fact is tho the Truth will never bend to the will of man..

Like it written those that help others yet don't help their own are worse then an infindel..


Hope all's well..
(⁠o⁠´⁠・⁠_⁠・⁠)⁠っ
But i'll ask again, who decides what is the Truth and whats a lie, do you, do i, cause i bet we'll have totally different views on so many issues about what constitutes the "truth", this is why we need to discuss our version of whats true, and perhaps sometimes admit that we were wrong and need to change our truth and accept that we were in fact living a lie, not intentionally , but still living a lie, ..... so i'll ask again, why do you think i'm telling lies about CK, whats your truth about CK and more importantly why do you believe that, then perhaps we can both examine why we feel the way we do and if i'm wrong i'll admit it, but if youre wrong i hope you'll do the same.

Hope alls well with you too.
 
But i'll ask again, who decides what is the Truth and whats a lie, do you, do i, cause i bet we'll have totally different views on so many issues about what constitutes the "truth", this is why we need to discuss our version of whats true, and perhaps sometimes admit that we were wrong and need to change our truth and accept that we were in fact living a lie, not intentionally , but still living a lie, ..... so i'll ask again, why do you think i'm telling lies about CK, whats your truth about CK and more importantly why do you believe that, then perhaps we can both examine why we feel the way we do and if i'm wrong i'll admit it, but if youre wrong i hope you'll do the same.

Hope alls well with you too.
But I will send you the Comforter from the Father. When he comes, he will give evidence about me. He is the Spirit of truth who comes from the Father...
The Lord has shown us all one gotta do hold counsel with the Lord in all things.. He does answer His children He does communicate with His children.. we as His children just gotta give Him the time to Hear Him to Allow Him to guide us in all our ways..

Ya ask how does one now how much to help or how to know what is Truth.. well the Lord Will reveal it to You so many seeking answers from man n many a man will provide an answer especially if one wanna pay for it but the Truth is all written for The people to see it's up to the people each and every one of us to Seek the Lord out and to Seek the Truth which only He is..
He tells us the kingdom of Heaven is within and it took me a long time to understand what He is saying and the Only reason I do it is because He revealed it to me.. man will never be able to teach spiritual teachings only the Spirit of the Lord can reveal and when He does one must not let their heart harden.. ya know when I first started to Heat Him I done thought I lost my mind.. to His voice was so much different then those I had all the years before that.. n then ones that would whisper to me boy oh boy they were not good at all no no no they were not..but the Lord His was inward and outward and all around and not once since I have begun developing this relationship I have with Him has He steered me into harming myself not those around me to put it simply..
See The Lord says who is the Greatest among us and He tells us it's the servant the one who serves that why He came to walk this world to Serve His Father and to show us the Way..He says the greatest gift one can give is their Life and He did just that . So how do we know when enough is enough in helping those who need help when the Lord calls us home then we know we have done enough l..


Ohhh idk I can be long winded perhaps I the Lord will send someone for me to Church with today in the flesh.. lol

Hope all's well . I so hope I'm at least partially keeping up with the convo..


This is good practice for me tho lol

Ttyl!!

(⁠o⁠´⁠・⁠_⁠・⁠)⁠っ
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rad
So, you are not correctly representing Charlies view. Sit back and think of the sin of a ''child sex offender''. It works up an emotion in all of us for an immediate death penalty. Do you think that if a sex offender repented of their sins and accepted Jesus as Lord, CK would call for their death? Yes or No?

Have you not seen the movie ''The sound of freedom''? I support the death penalty for all involved in this. You cannot have this in any society. There are governing laws required in a society that certainly over ride ''let him without sin cast the first stone'' that both Jesus and Paul acknowledged. As explained in my post directly above to you.
I think the death of any child should "work up an emotion" within us, not just those that are the victims of Sex offenders , but also those children who die through hunger, disease and war, who die in their millions just because theyre born into a world of Poverty and suffering, or who are born into war and destruction that blights so much of our world, should we execute ALL those responsible for such deaths, the queue would be ebdless, and who decides where it stops, no, the only answer is to live our lives as Christians with Justice, Mercy and Humility and leave the judgement and punishment to God who knows ALL and sees into our hearts.

Do i think CK would call for the death of a sex offender who repented of their sins, I dont know, seeing what i have of CK i doubt it, he spoke of a "life for a life", and seemed to be pleased about the deaths of those he considered unworthy of life, but who decides if theyve trfuly repented, who can see into the hearts of an offender and truly know theyre sorry for what theyve done but God alone, so who makes the call if their repentance is true and thus who shall live and who shall die, you, me, miserable sinners that we are pontificating on the fate of another miserable sinner?.

No i havent seen "The Sound of Freedom", ive just read an article about it, i'm wondering why you are so strongly against it but dont mention the many horrors going on in this world that are destroying people and the societies they live in, and as ive said before who decides which laws are required by a society to govern it properly?, remember in Nazi Germany, those that sheltered Anne Frank were breaking the law, those that Murdered her were following the law, you put too much faith in humanity, the only one we can truly trust and put our faith in is Christ, and his commandment that" Let him without sin cast the first stone" applies to us ALL, all those that profess to believe in him, no ifs or buts, that role of judgement and sentencing is his alone and not ours under any circumstances.

Could i also ask you a question that i asked Christ4Ever, Christ told a story of 2 men going to the temple to pray, a Pharisee and a Publican, the Pharisee trusted in his own righteousness, the Publican recognised what a miserable and unworthy sinner he was, who was justified, and who do you most identify with, a righteous man of God qualified to pass judgement on others, or an unworthy , miserable sinner that is only too well aware of his own wretched existence.?
 
But how do you know someone is "Stopping the work of God", despots and Charlatans throughout history have commanded that they are doing Gods work and that anyone that opposes them are opposing Gods will and are servants of the Devil, even the Nazis had "Gott mit Uns" on the belt buckles of their uniforms and Hitler wrote in Mein Kampf that in persecuting the Jews he was doing "the will of the Creator" and in the US today there are those that see Donald Trump as an instrument of God and any that oppose him as doing the work of the Devil.. So how would you know who is and who isnt "Stopping the work of God"?,

In the example given, God killed them. You and I cannot always discern this with others. But, we can with ourselves 1 Cor 11:31 For if we would judge ourselves, we should not be judged. Ananias and Saphira knew exactly what they were doing.

We can learn two important lessons from their example.

1. As a Christian committing or continuing in a mortal sin can result in God giving you a 'final destination type' death penalty.
2. Anyone opposing the work of the Holy Spirit, could receive a 'final destination type' death penalty.

It is important to note that Ananias and Saphira were a lot more informed about God than the average person. They were more accountable for their actions. Paul explains in 1 Cor 5 that we must not even eat at the same table as a Christian in a mortal sin, but if they are not a Christian, you can. That would apply to the examples you provided.

Again the question is who decides who is and who isnt "betraying jesus", as you rightly say we cant see into someones heart and soul, by definition ALL Christians believe they are following Christ in the way he wants them to, but given so many divergent views on what constitutes discipleship they cant all be right, so some are betraying Jesus, but who decides who they are, you, me, miserable sinners procalaiming who is the betrayer and who is true, i dont think so, leave that to God, who knows ALL and whose Judgement is righteous and just.

Similar to my explanation above, Christians are more accountable. Judas was an informed individual. All Christians and Jews are held to a higher level of accountability. Disciples probably as much as Christians as they walked with Jesus 24/7 and saw many miracles.

Same as comment above, the death penalty here is God's doing.

again, who decides what it means to "uphold God given laws that are required to properly govern a society", we have Christians from all sections of the political spectrum whose views on what constitutes "proper governance" differ widely, some see the cutting of provision for those in need, the massive spending on weapons and the military, the persecution of the "stranger" and the further enriching of the wealthy as "proper Governance", but is that what Christ commands, i think not, so to uphold a death sentence on those we deem "opposing Gods given laws that properly govern a society" would lead to a persecution reminiscent of the worst totalitarian regimes, Pinochet considered himself a Christian upholding Gods Laws in Chile by opposing Socialism and under his regime thousands were arrested, tortured and murdered, the same happened in Guatemala under Rios Montt in the 1980's when thousands of indigenous men, women and children were murdered in an attempt to destroy what the ruling military dictatorship held to be a threat to both Gods laws and the State. You are playing with fire, and when that happens ,people get burnt.

I feel you are creating rabbit trails.

The discussion is on moral laws and crimes that warrant capital punishment. Do you think Christians would disagree on an extremely long sentence for a murderer and the death penalty for a serial killer?

And who decides what murders have a "massive negative impact on Society",

Whoever is in power. Fortunately the USA has a good president. If perhaps Karmala was in, CK's killer would be out on bail.

CK's murder was public and aimed at sending a clear message to the right and to Christians.

would you call for the killer of the 2 democrat legislators a few months before CK 's murder to be put to death,

No, I am not a Democrat. I would need to hear the full case a couple of times before any prosecution as that party has shown itself to be evil and untrustworthy.

I am biased to Christian parties and Christian leaders. For obvious reasons.

and what of someone who slashes Overseas Aid causing the deaths of millions of the poorest men, women and children, should they be put to death for the "massive negative impact on their societies",

It would depend. If it is policies by the Democrats, the answer directly above applies.

or what of the arms sellers , bothy in the US and abroad, what of the Arms companies and the Politicians that supported them who sold Billions of $'s of weapons to Israel at the height of the genocide in Gaza where that society wasnt just massivrly negatively impacted", but totally destroyed, should they be put to death,

This is most often a grey area. Not always easy to prove and find a culprit. If I were a leader I would try to. I see Trump is trying. He should investigate Hillary on Libya for example. That was a massacre she needs to account for.

and what of the Oil, Coal and Gas corporations that have sold their products throughout the world knowing full well the "massive negative impact" it would have on societies, what punishment for them, or the Drug companies,

You are running with 'negative impact' into rabbit holes. Run with it from a Christian perspective.

We are A:LL sinners in a sinful world and NONE of us are so free of that sin that we can cast the first stone".

You are making that poor line say more than it was ever intended to say and you are incorrect.

Christians are not sin'ners'. Non Christians, fake Christians are. A Christian is by definition a repentant sinner Luke 5:32, Rev 3:20, psalm 51:17, James 4:8.

The context is judgement of punishment and a new dispensation Jesus was ushering in. Why did Jesus not say the law was wrong?

Quoting that line out of its context is pushing a half truth. Just like the devil did to Jesus in Matt 4.

You have yet to read and comment on this thread that explains the context of your cherry picked line - Are Christians to judge others?
 
In the example given, God killed them. You and I cannot always discern this with others. But, we can with ourselves 1 Cor 11:31 For if we would judge ourselves, we should not be judged. Ananias and Saphira knew exactly what they were doing.
We can learn two important lessons from their example.

1. As a Christian committing or continuing in a mortal sin can result in God giving you a 'final destination type' death penalty.
2. Anyone opposing the work of the Holy Spirit, could receive a 'final destination type' death penalty.

It is important to note that Ananias and Saphira were a lot more informed about God than the average person. They were more accountable for their actions. Paul explains in 1 Cor 5 that we must not even eat at the same table as a Christian in a mortal sin, but if they are not a Christian, you can. That would apply to the examples you provided.



Similar to my explanation above, Christians are more accountable. Judas was an informed individual. All Christians and Jews are held to a higher level of accountability. Disciples probably as much as Christians as they walked with Jesus 24/7 and saw many miracles.

Same as comment above, the death penalty here is God's doing.



I feel you are creating rabbit trails.

The discussion is on moral laws and crimes that warrant capital punishment. Do you think Christians would disagree on an extremely long sentence for a murderer and the death penalty for a serial killer?



Whoever is in power. Fortunately the USA has a good president. If perhaps Karmala was in, CK's killer would be out on bail.

CK's murder was public and aimed at sending a clear message to the right and to Christians.



No, I am not a Democrat. I would need to hear the full case a couple of times before any prosecution as that party has shown itself to be evil and untrustworthy.

I am biased to Christian parties and Christian leaders. For obvious reasons.



It would depend. If it is policies by the Democrats, the answer directly above applies.



This is most often a grey area. Not always easy to prove and find a culprit. If I were a leader I would try to. I see Trump is trying. He should investigate Hillary on Libya for example. That was a massacre she needs to account for.



You are running with 'negative impact' into rabbit holes. Run with it from a Christian perspective.



You are making that poor line say more than it was ever intended to say and you are incorrect.

Christians are not sin'ners'. Non Christians, fake Christians are. A Christian is by definition a repentant sinner Luke 5:32, Rev 3:20, psalm 51:17, James 4:8.

The context is judgement of punishment and a new dispensation Jesus was ushering in. Why did Jesus not say the law was wrong?

Quoting that line out of its context is pushing a half truth. Just like the devil did to Jesus in Matt 4.

You have yet to read and comment on this thread that explains the context of your cherry picked line - Are Christians to judge others?
Wow!!, i've got to say while reading that reply two quotes from Christ came to mind, "From the abundance of the Heart the mouth speaks", and "By their fruits you shall know them", and a bit later after reading it all, Christs words in Matthew 15:8 " ‘These people draw near to Me with their mouths, and they honor Me with their lips, but their hearts are far from Me", its hard to know just where to begin, theres so much thats so wrong about your way of thinking.

You start with the premise that you are a Christian, a follower of Christ, yet in truth i see little in your words that indicate that, you probably feel exactly the same about me, and i take it you judge yourself as i constantly judge myself against Christs words and commandments, but while you seem convinced in your own righteousness, your own certainty that you are a true follower of Christ , i see myself as a miserable sinner, constantly having to ask God for forgiveness for the wretched state of my life,........... and you never answered my question. Christ told a parable of 2 men who went to the Temple to pray, a Pharisee convinced of his own righteousness and a publican knowing just what a sinner he was, who do you most identify with?, i'd be interested to know

You seem to have tied your faith and your morality to a political Party which you believe is more "Christian", but i see little that is Christ like in either the Republican Party or its leader, the same as i see little that is Christ like in any political Party or their leaders, for they are ALL interested in power and Riches, and thats why i see the truth in Luke 4:6, for the Devil is truly in control of the Governments of this world. You have put your trust in Leaders, and you really need to read Matthew 24 particularly vs 24 to understand the dangers of this.

I would love to know just why you consider Trump to be such a "Good President", and which of his personal attributes and policies make him a good choice for a Christian to follow, I believe that we should follow no one, put our faith and our trust in no Earthly body, our faith and trust should be in God alone and our adherence alone to Christs teachings, to do any differently is to become as you put it, a "non or Fake Christian", who follows the teachings of men and not God.

It is obvious that we are going to have to agree to disagree on this issue, it seems that you consider yourself, as a repentant Christian, to be without sin and thus able to cast the first stone, seems to me thats a pretty big assumption on your part, how do you know youre not one of those many Christians that Christ will reject saying "i know you not", and how do you know that all your sins have been forgiven, especially if you continue to commit them, the possession of wealth and riches and a disregard for the poor and oppressed are mortal sins for which Christ will condemn those that commit them to eternal damnation, have you stopped perpetrating them?, have you asked for forgiveness?, and coming back to the this thread, i also think that the taking of life, any life, no matter what the reason ,is a sin, and those that support the death penalty will have to answer for their support of such an action when Christ clearly stated " Let him without sin cast the first stone" and "Do not judge ,... for what judgement you mete out will be given to you also".

I say again to you, "We are ALL sinners in a sinful world and NONE of us are so free of sin that we can cast the first stone", i pray you let those words sink deep into your Heart and that you too may be changed.

.
 
It is obvious that we are going to have to agree to disagree on this issue,

There is no agreeing to disagree. You dodge and pick the lines you read and digest. "There are none so blind as those who will not see."

I say again to you, "We are ALL sinners in a sinful world and NONE of us are so free of sin that we can cast the first stone", i pray you let those words sink deep into your Heart and that you too may be changed..

For the umpteenth time, you are cherry picking that line and clearly completely and utterly unteachable.

There is a very clear and ''duh'' world of difference between:

1. Mortal and venial sinners.
2. Repentant and unrepentant Christians.

In the OT in Hades, there was a separation of sinner and sinner. When you can grasp that we can discuss further.

--------------

Every single person that I have previously debated on the 'don't judge / cast first stone' line was guilty of approving of their own and or others sexual sins. The terrifying reality for you is that you will be 100% guilty of stumbling those in sexual sin. God hates the sexual sins of the LGBTQ++ community at the maximum level. It is mortal sin.

Now you may say well, all unrepentant sinners go to hell. Like many Christians here will say too. But I beg you to use the grey matter between your ears and grasp the obvious. If someone continues in mortal sin, you are closer to a hard heart / being sold out to a love what is evil / point of no return over any venial sinner. You are guilty of pushing sinners down a steep slope, straight into hell.

You need to read and meditate on Matt 18:6 If anyone causes one of these little ones those who believe in me to stumble, it would be better for them to have a large millstone hung around their neck and to be drowned in the depths of the sea.
 
Rightly gained is open for discussion :). Not too much discussion though as there is a very real space where light needs to remove darkness. In many wars with pagans it was a case of either 'we do it' or wait on God to 'do it' with plagues, floods, fire and brimstone.

Reality is that all religions vie for national control. It is so good to know there are 'Christian' nations. Either Catholic or Protestant. Both are fine. If there were not, it would just be a matter of time before Muslims would want full control, or Hindus or atheists. The smaller religions would also want full control if they had the numbers.
No, it isn't.
Christians settled the land and by rights is theirs. Muslims invaded, killed and drove most of the Christians out, so the Crusades were justified and any things done to them by Christians IS just and right.
Your or any else's opinion otherwise is irrelevant.

If Christians had invaded Muslim lands would not the same be said of them if they had gone to war to gain what was rightfully theirs? Yes.
Islam by default and definition is an evil death cult.
 
No, it isn't.
Christians settled the land and by rights is theirs. Muslims invaded, killed and drove most of the Christians out, so the Crusades were justified and any things done to them by Christians IS just and right.
Your or any else's opinion otherwise is irrelevant.

If Christians had invaded Muslim lands would not the same be said of them if they had gone to war to gain what was rightfully theirs? Yes.
Islam by default and definition is an evil death cult.

Your original line stated 'Fun fact: Any lands that were Christian to begin with were rightly gained and any attack on Muslims regardless is also just.'.

Not all land that is Christian now was rightly gained. That was the only point being made. If you are thinking solely on wars with Muslims and the crusades, I guess I would agree with you on most of it.
 
No, it isn't.
Christians settled the land and by rights is theirs. Muslims invaded, killed and drove most of the Christians out, so the Crusades were justified and any things done to them by Christians IS just and right.
Your or any else's opinion otherwise is irrelevant.

If Christians had invaded Muslim lands would not the same be said of them if they had gone to war to gain what was rightfully theirs? Yes.
Islam by default and definition is an evil death cult.
The crusade werent about taking back the lands they took from Christendom, that was done early on before the crusades. Mostly spain was taken back from the muslims. From fighting the muslims, they recognized that Jerusalem was under muslim control and felt that the land of Israel should not suffer living under Islam, so many christian nations sent forth crusaders against the lands of Israel to take the Holy Land away from Islamic control and they succeeded for a time before Saladin came along, and for the first time rallied many islamic tribes together and drove them out. But the crusades also did some dark things as well, like sacked the mostly christian city of constantinople. They decided that they wanted any christian relics that might be found there and didnt care about taking it from other christians through force and killing.

Now the muslims needed to respect christendom and the crusades did that to them. Prior to the crusades, christian nations were to muslims just another infidel nation that needed conquering. It was the first major setback to the muslim conquest of Mediterranean lands starting in north africa, and then the Iberian peninsula. Over land closer to turkey which was muslim held, Constantinople held constant battles back and forth with the muslims and when it finally fell, and the muslims ventured further into eastern europe, vlad the impaler scared the crap out of them with how he treated any captured muslims. They feared the wrath that vlad had for them. The combination of vlad and the crusades kept them out of europe for quite some time. Current day instanbul is as far as they got as for holding any european lands.
 
The crusade werent about taking back the lands they took from Christendom, that was done early on before the crusades. Mostly spain was taken back from the muslims. From fighting the muslims, they recognized that Jerusalem was under muslim control and felt that the land of Israel should not suffer living under Islam, so many christian nations sent forth crusaders against the lands of Israel to take the Holy Land away from Islamic control and they succeeded for a time before Saladin came along, and for the first time rallied many islamic tribes together and drove them out. But the crusades also did some dark things as well, like sacked the mostly christian city of constantinople. They decided that they wanted any christian relics that might be found there and didnt care about taking it from other christians through force and killing.

Now the muslims needed to respect christendom and the crusades did that to them. Prior to the crusades, christian nations were to muslims just another infidel nation that needed conquering. It was the first major setback to the muslim conquest of Mediterranean lands starting in north africa, and then the Iberian peninsula. Over land closer to turkey which was muslim held, Constantinople held constant battles back and forth with the muslims and when it finally fell, and the muslims ventured further into eastern europe, vlad the impaler scared the crap out of them with how he treated any captured muslims. They feared the wrath that vlad had for them. The combination of vlad and the crusades kept them out of europe for quite some time. Current day instanbul is as far as they got as for holding any european lands.
In summary and essence:
Islam is an evil death cult.
Allah is Satan.
Anything bad that happens to them is 100% justified.
God will eradicate that cult and all Muslims.
 
Your original line stated 'Fun fact: Any lands that were Christian to begin with were rightly gained and any attack on Muslims regardless is also just.'.

Not all land that is Christian now was rightly gained. That was the only point being made. If you are thinking solely on wars with Muslims and the crusades, I guess I would agree with you on most of it.
All of human existence is full of one country/culture conquering another until one point where there isn't any left.
There are winners and losers.
Regarding "not all land that is Christian was rightfully gained" - Evidence?
Is there hundreds of years on-going litigation and court deliberation and such? No.
Fun fact: America is not "stolen land" either.
 
There is no agreeing to disagree. You dodge and pick the lines you read and digest. "There are none so blind as those who will not see."
As i said "We'll have to agree to disagree", i feel exactly the same way about you that you do about me, to discuss you have to have at least some common ground, but i feel like our discussion is similar to one between a member of the Ku Klux Klan and a BLM supporter, .... sadly, it never fails to amaze me how 2 people, both claiming to follow Christ can have such differing views on what it means to be a Christian
For the umpteenth time, you are cherry picking that line and clearly completely and utterly unteachable.

There is a very clear and ''duh'' world of difference between:

1. Mortal and venial sinners.
2. Repentant and unrepentant Christians.

In the OT in Hades, there was a separation of sinner and sinner. When you can grasp that we can discuss further.
As i say, i feel exactly the same way about you, but could you answer my question for the "umpteenth time", Christ told the story of 2 men that went into the temple to pray, a Pharisee and a Publican, the Publican was assured of his own righteousness before God, the Pharisee was only too aware of what a wretched Soul he was, who do you most identify with?, ........ and i will ask this question again for the umpteenth time, "How do you know that youre even a Christian and not one of the "many" that claim to be Christians but whom Christ will disown saying " i know you not", because ive got to say to me youre coming across as someone who's so assured of their righteousness, so assured of the truth of their convictions, when in effect NONE of us know either for sure, for that is Gods prerogative alone.
--------------

Every single person that I have previously debated on the 'don't judge / cast first stone' line was guilty of approving of their own and or others sexual sins. The terrifying reality for you is that you will be 100% guilty of stumbling those in sexual sin. God hates the sexual sins of the LGBTQ++ community at the maximum level. It is mortal sin.
Well heres the first one then that didnt, just out of interest how many people have you debated with on the " 'don't judge / cast first stone' line"?, I am only too well aware of my own sexual sins, of the number of times ive looked on a woman with lust in my heart , of the evil thoughts that permeate from my sinful heart, we are ALL guilty of them and the LGBT community is no different, we are ALL guilty of sexual and so many other sins, and perhaps you should look at the log of sin in your own eye so you can see clearly to remove the speck thats in others you are so keen to condemn . I know there are certain "Christians" who see the sins of the LGBTQ community as warranting their most venomous disapproval, now i'm not saying that its not a sin, God knows we ALL sin, but it never fails to amaze me that this "Mortal Sin" was never once mentioned by Christ in the Gospels, now you'd have thought that something so abhorent to him would have been mentioned at least once, but no, nothing, however what is mentioned and conveniently overlooked by so many Christians, is Christs Abhorence of Wealth and Riches and those that possess them , of the lack of Compassion and Justice by those that profess to follow him and the hypocrisy of those that overlook their own mortal sins but are only too keen to condemn others,
CK was i believe a very rich man, i even saw him advertising Gold on one of his podcasts, on the admittedly limited videos i've seen of him Compassion and Justice didnt seem to be high on his agenda but Condemnation and pointing the finger at others was a common theme, this is why i asked right at the start of this discourse for others to show me their "best" clips of CK as i wanted to get a more complete picture of the man, but for what ever reason that wasn't forthcoming.
And God hates ALL sin with Christ emphasising the sins of Wealth and Riches, Hypocrisy and a lack of Compassion as worthy of the greatest punishment. You would do well to heed this.

Now you may say well, all unrepentant sinners go to hell. Like many Christians here will say too. But I beg you to use the grey matter between your ears and grasp the obvious. If someone continues in mortal sin, you are closer to a hard heart / being sold out to a love what is evil / point of no return over any venial sinner. You are guilty of pushing sinners down a steep slope, straight into hell.

You need to read and meditate on Matt 18:6 If anyone causes one of these little ones those who believe in me to stumble, it would be better for them to have a large millstone hung around their neck and to be drowned in the depths of the sea.
The problem is , to repent , you have to first of all recognise that what you're doing is in fact a sin, i have had so many conversations over the last 30 years with Christians, those that profess to follow Christ, about the incompatibility of the possession of great wealth and living a life of relative comfort in a world of such abject poverty, suffering, death and destruction, of the fact that our lives are built upon the oppression and exploitation of others and that we live in societies that are destroying Gods creation for material gain.
Few want to recognise that they are "living in sin", they want to see themselves as "good" Christians following Christs teachings, whereas in fact we are ALL wretched sinners living lives of Selfishness, lust and greed.
So yes, i understand the reality of my sinful life, i acknowledge that i continue in "mortal sin", but i try, thats the best i can say, to Love my neighbour as myself , treat others as i would want to be treated, to act with Justice, to Love Mercy and above all, to walk Humbly with my God, for i know just how much i'm in need of his mercy and forgiveness.

As for Christs words in Matthew 18:6, yes i am guilty of harming those little ones that believe in Christ, i have too often turned away when i see the starving children, those enduring hardship and abuse trying just to survive, those enduring the horrors of war and violence, turned away because it would cost me too much, both financially and emotionally to open my heart fully to them as Christ asks me to do, so again, and how many times do i have to say this, I am a wretched sinner, bereft of all goodness, but i try to do better, i try to give more of myself, more of my time, more of my money and more of my Love and compassion, but i know just how far i fall short between what i could do and what i actually do.

But let me ask you a question, you seem to have placed your Faith with Tump and his MAGA sect, calling him a "Good President" and calling the Democrats "Evil and untrustworthy", so how many of "those little ones that believe in Christ" do you think Trump has caused to "stumble" with his massive cuts to Overseas Aid which according to reports will cost in the region of 14 million lives, and how many of those Little ones that believe in Christ will "stumble" because of his cuts to SNAP benefits and Health provision for the poorest in the US, and what of Trumps support and massive provision of weapons to the Israeli military enabling the Genocide of Palestinians, how many little ones there will be forced to "stumble", and what do you think Christ will say to those that support the man who has implemented these policies, perhaps here we have an example of those to whom Christ will say " i know you not, depart from me you workers of iniquity" "
 
In summary and essence:
Islam is an evil death cult.
Allah is Satan.
Anything bad that happens to them is 100% justified.
God will eradicate that cult and all Muslims.
Seems to me that in your desire to condemn Islam and justify any atrocity perpetrated against its followers you are allying youself to the worst acts in history. "Killing for Christ" became a mantra of the Crusades and all subsequent Holy wars and as such have nothing to do with Christ or of those that profess to follow him. Christ said the 2 greatest Commandments were to "Love God with ALL your Heart ,soul and mind and your Neighbour as yourself", he said that the whole of the Law and the Prophets could be summed up by the words "Treat others as you would want to be treated", no ifs or buts, no second guessing, no "but what about......", just Love others as yourself and treat others as youd want to be treated, and in Matthew 5 vs 38-48 Christ says "

"Eye for Eye​

38“You have heard that it was said, ‘Eye for eye, and tooth for tooth.’ 39;But I tell you, do not resist an evil person. If anyone slaps you on the right cheek, turn to them the other cheek also. 40;And if anyone wants to sue you and take your shirt, hand over your coat as well. 41;If anyone forces you to go one mile, go with them two miles. 42;Give to the one who asks you, and do not turn away from the one who wants to borrow from you.

Love for Enemies​

43“You have heard that it was said, ‘Love your neighbor and hate your enemy.’ 44;But I tell you, love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you, 45;that you may be children of your Father in heaven. He causes his sun to rise on the evil and the good, and sends rain on the righteous and the unrighteous. 46;If you love those who love you, what reward will you get? Are not even the tax collectors doing that? 47;And if you greet only your own people, what are you doing more than others? Do not even pagans do that? 48;Be perfect, therefore, as your heavenly Father is perfect."

Youve really got to banish the hate you seem to feel from your Heart and understand that God alone will decide the judgement and punishment to be given, not us, for we are Sinners " who have no right to judge others and "cast the first stone" of condemnation,
I have seen a video where CK says " God hates everything that i do", and when you believe that, when you know the mind of God when it comes to judgement and punishment then you are capable of the most horrendous atrocities as evidenced throughout history, for as Pascal said "Men never do evil so completely and cheerfully as when they do it from religious conviction.".
 
We can already see you've taken verses out of context.
You make assumptions such as "desire to condem Islam" It and Muslims have done that on their own.
Let's start with your lie #1.
"worst acts in history. "Killing for Christ" became a mantra of the Crusades and all subsequent Holy wars".
Muslims were GUILTY of invading Christians lands and all that, not innocent.
There is no historical record of that phrase being used as a chant/matnra in the Crusades. What is documented:

1. Papal and clerical rhetoric emphasized “fighting for Christ” or “liberating Christ’s tomb,” not killing in His name.

Examples from documented sources:
  • Urban II’s speech at Clermont (1095) — described in various chronicles as urging Christians to defend fellow Christians and reclaim Jerusalem.
    Phrasing varies by chronicler, but none record anything like “killing for Christ.”
  • Crusader slogans and battle shouts:
    • “Deus vult!” (“God wills it”)
    • “Christus vincit!” (“Christ conquers”)
So, you're either a liar or highly ignorant or real history.
Eye for an eye - "The Old Testament Law of Retaliation.

1. Limit retaliation

It prevented escalation of conflicts, a major issue in tribal societies.
Without this rule:
  • One injury could lead to a cycle of revenge killingsFamilies or clans could retaliate far beyond the harm done.
“Eye for an eye” was a way to say:

Punishment must be proportional—not greater than the original harm.
That was a major ethical improvement for its time.

2. Standardize justice

It ensured judges gave consistent, fair penalties, rather than arbitrary or overly severe punishments.

3. Primarily result in compensation, not bodily mutilation

Rabbinic interpretation (which reflects much older practice) held that monetary compensation was typically used, not literal physical injury.
The Talmud is explicit: the verses mandate financial damages, not physical retribution (Bava Kamma 83b–84a).
Anthropologically, most ancient Near Eastern cultures—including the Code of Hammurabi—used the same language metaphorically to mean proportionate compensation.

God commanded early Christians to "kill" His enemies.

Strke 2 and not looking good for you.

Love for enemies. - In essence, love first, trust conditionally as God does.
God will NOT let any unrepentant sinner into Heaven. He still loves them more than any human could but salvation and eternity with him is conditional.

Your cherry picked here, out of context of course, is an example of a goal. No person can be perfect but can they work towards it. OF COURSE.

Assumption: "banish the hate you seem to feel from your Heart". I don't know any Muslims as they are repulse by us and want to kill us.
The Judge....has already spoken and spreading the Gospel includes what the Judge has said on everything.
I've never stated, "I think...." in something regarding God and the Bible. On this problematic death cult, God has already told us how to respond. Self-presevation. Defense of others and death of the evil person if it comes to it.
God never states we should let evil go unchecked.

CK isn't God nor is he the authority (like the Pope) in the church.
I'm not Catholic.
"you are capable of the most horrendous atrocities as evidenced throughout history" - New Flash:
SO ARE YOU.

 

The People God Commands You NOT to Help (Biblical Truth)

1. Lazy. "If anyone is not willing to work, let him not eat." - 2 Thessalonians 3:10-12
This applies to:
  • those who are able to work
  • but refuse
  • and instead burden others deliberately
2. People who persist in evil and refuse correction.
"A man of great wrath will suffer punishment; if you rescue him, you will have to do it again.” - Proverbs 19:19
  • Don’t “rescue” someone who is destructively violent or sinful
  • when helping them only leads to repeating the cycle
  • or when they refuse correction and accountability

2. People who teach a false gospel or deceive others.
"If anyone comes to you and does not bring this teaching, do not receive him into your house or give him any greeting…" - 2 John 10-11

3. People who call themselves Christian yet live in open, unrepentant sin.
1 Corinthians 5:11–13
Paul commands believers not to associate with someone who:
  • claims to be Christian
  • but lives in ongoing, deliberate sin
So, Rad. I urge you to do a lot more digging into God's word on anything.
The Judge has spoken and repeating what the Judge said is what we are commanded to do.
Fight and rebuke evil even it means "sending them to God" sooner.

 
Back
Top