Dear Brother Steve,
You probably won't like this post much.
If your posts are what you truly believe Brother Nick and are delivered in a spirit of understanding and Compassion, both of which are true, then how could i possibly not like them. You have your view, i have mine, and surely one of the reasons for these discussion boards is to present those views to each other as a means of ascertaining Gods truth for our lives.
The problem is you have to. Why? Because as scripture also says, Philippians 2:4 Let each of you look out not only for his own interests, but also for the interests of others.
Meaning not just doing good, but you must also consider what it means to another. Otherwise, you in truth could be doing them harm and not the good you think you are doing if it were you.
So, you love peanuts, but they're allergic to them....The basis of your love is in Jesus, but the good that you do, is based off of what you consider to be good? I don't think that is what Jesus meant.
I think we are somewhat at cross purposes here Brother Nick. I am talking of fundamental Human needs, Food, clothing, shelter, clean water, provision of healthcare, aid to the imprisoned and the welcoming of the "stranger" and i believe our response to these needs is universal as Christ stated in Matthew 25 vs 31-46, if we are hungry we need food, if we are naked, we need clothes, if we are without shelter, we need homes, if we are sick we need medical care, if we are imprisoned we need support and if we are a stranger we need welcoming. And when Christ said "Treat others as you'd want to be treated" then i think there are few of us that wouldnt want these basic needs to be met. Indeed ,if we believe Christs words in Matthew 25, then in the person of the suffering and needy we see him and our response to those in need will be a determinant in our ultimate Salvation or otherwise.
The example that Jesus was saying, has to do with how people addressed the issue of helping others i.e. Good Samritan story; which is that most people are selfish, and look after their own interests, and will not help others unless there is personal gain or does not inconvenience them. So, a person will do for themselves what they would not do for another, is not how Jesus ever worked, nor how He expects us to work. If you truly love them, and want to do good for them, you will consider them in what you do, because in truth what is good for you does not mean it will be good for them, for it's not about you but them. Leaving it up to Jesus is taking the easy way out and abdicates your own responsibilities to doing good to others, after all isn't this about you and not them?
I believe the parable of the Good Samaritan was in response to "who is my Neighbour", who should we "Love as ourselves?, to which Christ portrayed a member of an outcast community, the Samaritans", helping a complete stranger in dire need while the "righteous" religious folk walked on by. Those in need are our "Neighbours" who we must love as ourselves and treat as we would want to be treated. The Good Samaritan didnt stop to think, he just acted out of Love and compassion and helped as best he could. And that isnt advocating my responsibility Brother Nick, its hard, well it is for me, to love others as ourselves, our inherent selfishness pulls us one way, Christs commandments and our own Love and compassion pull us the other, and we usually end up somewhere in the middle, doing something but not all we could do, and asking God for forgiveness for our wretched sinfulness. Oh no, its not easy, not an abdication, but an acceptance of the lives we lead and how far we are from the Love we profess.
No, the question is what exactly is Jesus wanting me to do? You say Love and Compassion, but what does those translate to? He's not telling us exactly what that is but gives us enough to know that what we do must uplift the other as we would want to be uplifted. I have a person who lives in a hut, and then move him to NYC, or London. You can even reverse this as well. How are they to get along, when all they might know is plowing a field, and have never ridden a transit vehicle in their life, or bought food in a store with money instead of bartering? No job. Not even considering the language differences, speaking, reading, and the list goes on. This is why I truly believe it is questionable at best the process you are looking to affect another's life, without proper consideration which I mention previously. You must consider them, or are you lacking the love for them to do go that far, and want Jesus to take care of it?
Without repeating myself Brother Nick, i believe that our Love and Compassion is encapsulated in "Loving your neighbour as yourself, treating others as youd want to be treated and the practical application of that philosophy is portrayed in the Sheep and the goats, feeding the hungry, clothing the naked, housing the homeless etc..... and as for the person living in a hut, their needs would probably be far simpler than you state, they'd want improved housing, clean water, help with their crops, schooling and healthcare for them and their children and if they had to flee their homes due to war , violence, persecution of climatic shocks then a loving acceptance and welcome as strangers. And i believe that on this Earth, we are called to be Gods hands and feet , we are called to be his instruments of Love and compassion, we are called to give our all for those in need regardless of the consequences, its not a question of letting " Jesus take care of it", but acting in a way that s guided by his teaching and shows Gods love to this suffering world.
No what you are doing, is what "you" consider what is best for another and blaming Jesus for it! lol Oh, I agree with the needs of people, but you must know those people to know their needs! You say in truth that you only need to know how you yourself would satisfy that need for it to be handled, to provide for another, but in truth are you going to be able to do what is good for them, by using your own life as a template without their own life/experiences being considered?
But we cant "know these people" Brother Nick, atm there are tens of millions of people in Sudan and hundreds of millions more across Gods world facing hunger and starvation, are we to ask each one of them what they want before we act, or do we do as Christ commanded and Feed the Hungry. And i believe that if we truly have gods Love within us then when we act out of love and compassion we are indeed doing the right thing, as ive said basic human needs are pretty universal and so therefore must our response be.Food for the hungry, water for the thirsty, homes for the homeless.........
Have you felt those very same needs, whatever they may be, that you are trying to pull others from? I imagine some you do, but be honest, where many of these migrants are coming from, are not your own experiences make. Nor mine. I would not even begin to speak to believing that my life till now, can be compared to theirs, nor would I necessarily want them to have mine either! In many ways, their own lives through hardships and all, have many virtues that we have lost due to our technological advancements. If you don't see this, then you haven't looked close enough around our modern society.
The truth is i havent experienced any of the horrendous sufferings that so many others have to endure Brother Nick, but thats where empathy comes in, we have a unique capacity to understand what others are going through, well understand as best we can, when we see a mother with a dying infant in her arms, or a man trying to provide for his family although war and drought have devastated all he had, or a child breathing their last as they die from Measles or Malaria, we can feel their pain, feel their heartache, understand as best we can their suffering, and the solution becomes clear, the only question is do we have the Love, Compassion and Faith to follow through on our understanding
It truly goes a lot deeper than the simplification that you have presented, and from what I can tell in this last post of yours. Which you excuse yourself from having to deal with. For in truth, you're not really helping them for their sake, but assuaging your conscience in the believe you are complying with the commandments of Jesus and are able to wash your hands of the repercussions of it by laying it at Jesus' feet when it becomes harmful to them and doesn't turn out as it did for you.
And there is truth in what you say brother Nick, i do act partly to assuage my Guilt, my guilt at doing so little, my guilt at having so much when others have nothing, my guilt at living in wealth and comfort while others live and die in poverty and deprivation, my guilt at professing my faith of love and compassion but of doing do little to express that faith in action, oh yes Brother Nick, there is guilt there, but i also hope that there is compassion as well, and Love, and of trying to do more. And if you knew me better then youd know i dont Wash my hands of the repercussions by laying it at Jesus feet when it becomes harmful", much heartache and questioning has led to so many sleepless nights over the years, 2 cases may perhaps illustrate this, after the Rwandan genocide in 1994 many of the perpetrators and their families fled Rwanda to the DRC where they set up refugee camps and continued their genocidal attacks on Rwanda, do you feed those people, do you care for them, do you enable their atrocities, and if you dont then are their children who will die as a result on your conscience?, i gave my money but never fully answered that question. And after the 1985 famine in Ethiopia where millions of pounds was donated in humanitarian relief and many lives were saved, a whole generation of orphans grew up without parents and living in foster homes. Theres a good chance that some of those same orphans joined the army as a stable"home" and steady income that theyd never had. In 2008 , 23 years later, Ethiopia invaded Somalia and their soldiers committed horrific atrocities, theres a good chance that those very same children i helped to survive went on to commit those horrors, so am i in some way culpable. I think you misunderstand me brothert Nick, when i say "Leave the rest to Christ", i say that in the knowledge of his ultimate power and authority and in no way diminish the responsibility i feel for my own actions.
Sorry brother, for being a bit harsh in this response. You take the bitter with the sweet, in this. For as I've said it before, in truth I do admire what you seek to do, but the process leaves much to be desired. For if you're doing it to comply with Jesus' Commandments, how different are you then those who followed the OT laws, in the attempt of doing what is right, not for others sake, but for themselves. This is not loving brother, which is the most important Commandment, of which all others rest upon. You must love the Lord your God with all your heart and might. And you must love them as you love yourself, which is not about material things, but spiritual ones brother. Your thoughts are worldly as if it's materialistic things that we work with communicates or shows that you love them. It does not.
Youve not been harsh at all Brother Nick, and i greatly respect your understanding way of posting, we disagree on many points but can do so in a spirit of tolerance and love, as it should be between fellow believers. And i dont treat Christs commandments as a sort of "checklist" that must be followed. To me Christs words are a living testament , the only solid rock i have in my life on which i can hopefully build my faith based on his truths. And i often question the nature of my "Love", i guess its an emotional involvement with the suffering in this world, as i said in one of my previous posts i believe our faith is based on our heart and not our mind, we need to open our hearts to the pain around us and do all we can to show Gods love in this fallen world, this is what it means to me to "take up my Cross", a life of pain and sacrifice in the cause of Love, but before i get too carried away with what i know i should do, the reality is often so different, the only thing i can say is that i try, with the strength my faith gives me , to do better, and i reckon thats all any of us can do.
And its about material and spiritual things brother Nick, the Sermon on the mount is all about how we should lead our lives in the service of others, the parable of the Good Samaritan is about helping our "brother" in need, the Sheep and the goats is all about the material love and compassion we must show to the poor and outcast, Lazarus and the rich man shows the dangers of living a materially rich life while others die from poverty and hunger, Zacchaeus was only saved after he had agreed to give half his fortune to the poor and return 4 fold what he'd received by extortion, The rich man was told to "Give all he had to the poor and come follow Christ and he shall have Treasure in heaven", a call Christ re-iterated a number of times, we are to "Let our good works shine so that men may seem them and glorify our Father in Heaven. There is no division between the material and the spiritual Brother Nick for both are so closely entwined in our lives that to try to separate them is both futile and against christs teaching.
I love you brother, because you have shared with me of your inner self, and not a morsal of food or shelter have you given me. Give them Jesus, and you will have given them more than if you'd given them the world.
We need to give them both Brother Nick, for is that not what we would want in their place, and the best way we can Give and Show Gods Love for them is in our actions of love and Compassion. It is not either/or, it is both Brother Nick, the complete package of Gods love for his suffering world.
With the love of Christ Jesus Brother Nick
Steve
With the Love of Christ Jesus Brother Steve!
YBIC
Nick