Paul's third missionary journey
44 - First letter to the Corinthians
It is difficult to give a brief summary of Paul's letters. I would simply like to mention the main themes to help us better understand them and appreciate their depth.
If we want to know Paul, his fiery temperament, his passion for the Gospel, his freedom of speech and his determination, it is in the two epistles to the Corinthians that we must look for them. The first was probably written in the spring of 54. But Paul had already written to the Christians in Corinth. Two of his letters have been lost.
The community of Corinth was founded by Paul in the year 50. In Ephesus, he regularly received news from his Churches and he reacted by writing or sending collaborators. The situation in Corinth appears quite troubled. Judeo-Christians (Jews who converted to Christianity and remained faithful to Hebrew Law) have wreaked havoc and are responsible for much of the community's problems. Paul's authority is shaken. So he sends his spiritual son, Timothy, to check the situation. When he returned, Paul decided to write to this Church in disarray.
The problems are numerous. First there is the division into different factions: some call themselves disciples of Apollos, others of Paul, others of Peter and still others of Jesus Christ himself. All this divides the community. Then there are the behaviors that scandalize: incest, fornication, trials before the city courts. The liturgical assembly is troubled by unacceptable differences between rich and poor. Under the pretext of “science” and “freedom”, we indulge in sterile discussions on virginity and marriage. Paul offers us here the first reflections on a Christian ethics applied to the problems of love, marriage, the role of women in the Church, and social conditions.
The Gospel is a law that is not imposed from the outside, like the Mosaic law, but it transforms from the inside.
Paul traces the surest route to living the Gospel: brotherly love. The famous hymn to charity in chapter 13 describes this love by highlighting the disorders that disrupt the church of Corinth. The Corinthians tend to reduce the gifts of the Spirit to spectacular manifestations like “prayer in tongues” (glossolalia) and “prophecy.” Paul reminds them that it is not the spectacle that characterizes the gifts of the Spirit, but service to the community: “Even if I speak in tongues, that of men and that of angels, if I lack love , I am a resonating metal, a clanging cymbal. Even if I had the gift of prophecy, the knowledge of all mysteries and all knowledge, when I had the most complete faith, that which moves mountains, if I lack love, I am nothing . If I distribute all my goods to the hungry, when I deliver my body to the flames, if I lack love, I gain nothing. Love takes patience, love is of service, it does not jealous, it does not show off, it does not get puffed up with pride, it does nothing ugly, it does not seek its own interest, it does not does not irritate, he does not harbor grudges, he does not rejoice in injustice, but he finds his joy in the truth. He excuses everything, he believes everything, he hopes everything, he endures everything. Love never passes. The prophecies? They will be abolished. Languages? They will end. The knowledge? It will be abolished. [...] These three remain: faith, hope and love, but love is the greatest. (1Co 13, 1-13)
The hymn to love is a high point of New Testament writings. It is one of the most beautiful texts in world literature. It is often repeated during wedding ceremonies. Among the many charisms, the way of love is the charisma par excellence.
Freedom is one of the main themes addressed by Paul in this first letter to the Corinthians. He ardently defends Christian freedom against Judeo-Christians who want to impose the Law of Moses and Jewish customs on non-Jewish believers. He led this fight at the Council of Jerusalem and he will do it again in his epistle to the Galatians. In the Greek and Latin world, political and democratic freedom included the right to speak for all members of the citizens' assembly (the ekklesia) and the right to say everything (parrèsia), without fear of reprisals. Paul claims these rights for himself and for his churches.
Like the Stoics, Paul is a fierce defender of personal conscience. Regarding the consumption of meat offered to idols, he recalls that idols are nothing. We can therefore eat the meat offered to them (8, 4-6). But this freedom must be limited by fraternal charity towards those who risk being scandalized by this freedom (8, 7-13).
Paul does not intend to impose his own laws and he in no way claims to exercise spiritual tyranny: “It is not that we intend to rule your faith, we only want to contribute to your joy” (2 Cor. 1, 24). The Gospel is not a straitjacket. It is a law that is not imposed from the outside, like the Mosaic law, but it transforms from the inside.
According to Paul, Christians must change their view of Jesus as Paul himself did during his conversion in Damascus: Jesus must no longer be considered “cursed” because he was crucified, but as the “resurrected Lord”. The four gospels will mention the torture of the cross as the mode of execution of Jesus, but they will not do the theology of the cross. It is Paul who does it, and this for the first time in this epistle to the Corinthians (1 Cor 1, 18-31). This is his major contribution to Christian theology. The cross is a revelation. It tells us who God is for us. In the message of the cross, Paul discovers a God who surpasses all wisdom and all religion. It is there that he manifests his wisdom and his power, even where man sees only weakness and folly.
In this epistle, the Apostle's thoughts revolve around two poles: the Lord's Supper and fraternal love. The Eucharist is a source of nourishment for fraternal love. In Corinth, the feast had degenerated into a feast for some, while others did not have enough to eat.
Paul also answers questions received about the role of women during the celebrations. They asked to be assimilated to men in offices. They spoke there, and did not wear a veil. Paul advises the wearing of the veil, which corresponds to an almost universal habit in his time. We know that the prostitutes of Corinth went bareheaded. Christian women without veils thus risked being compared to the prostitutes of the port city. When it came to speaking in congregations, Paul followed Jewish custom in synagogues, which earned him the accusation of being a misogynist. It must be emphasized, however, that throughout his letters, women appear who campaign alongside him and play a leading role, a role that was forbidden to them in the synagogues and in Greek and Roman institutions. They have important positions in the Churches. In Corinth itself one is minister or deaconess of a community. Among the Christians cited by Paul in his epistles are nine women to whom, on several occasions, he expresses esteem and affection.
Paul devotes the last chapter of this epistle to faith in the resurrection (1 Cor 15). The letter began with “the language of the Cross” and ended with the proclamation of the resurrection of Christ and the announcement of the resurrection of believers. It is therefore framed by the Paschal mystery.
That's a lot of topics for one letter. The First Epistle to the Corinthians is long, extremely dense and surprisingly varied, but it is extraordinarily rich and allows us to take a look at the life of the early Church. However, it seems that it did not have the expected effect. During the summer of 54, when Timothy returned to Ephesus, he reported that he had been very poorly received in Corinth. Anyone other than Paul would have been discouraged. He holds on. He never gives up. The crisis will rebound and give rise to other interventions, to other visits from Paul and Titus, to other letters.
44 - First letter to the Corinthians
It is difficult to give a brief summary of Paul's letters. I would simply like to mention the main themes to help us better understand them and appreciate their depth.
If we want to know Paul, his fiery temperament, his passion for the Gospel, his freedom of speech and his determination, it is in the two epistles to the Corinthians that we must look for them. The first was probably written in the spring of 54. But Paul had already written to the Christians in Corinth. Two of his letters have been lost.
The community of Corinth was founded by Paul in the year 50. In Ephesus, he regularly received news from his Churches and he reacted by writing or sending collaborators. The situation in Corinth appears quite troubled. Judeo-Christians (Jews who converted to Christianity and remained faithful to Hebrew Law) have wreaked havoc and are responsible for much of the community's problems. Paul's authority is shaken. So he sends his spiritual son, Timothy, to check the situation. When he returned, Paul decided to write to this Church in disarray.
The problems are numerous. First there is the division into different factions: some call themselves disciples of Apollos, others of Paul, others of Peter and still others of Jesus Christ himself. All this divides the community. Then there are the behaviors that scandalize: incest, fornication, trials before the city courts. The liturgical assembly is troubled by unacceptable differences between rich and poor. Under the pretext of “science” and “freedom”, we indulge in sterile discussions on virginity and marriage. Paul offers us here the first reflections on a Christian ethics applied to the problems of love, marriage, the role of women in the Church, and social conditions.
The Gospel is a law that is not imposed from the outside, like the Mosaic law, but it transforms from the inside.
Paul traces the surest route to living the Gospel: brotherly love. The famous hymn to charity in chapter 13 describes this love by highlighting the disorders that disrupt the church of Corinth. The Corinthians tend to reduce the gifts of the Spirit to spectacular manifestations like “prayer in tongues” (glossolalia) and “prophecy.” Paul reminds them that it is not the spectacle that characterizes the gifts of the Spirit, but service to the community: “Even if I speak in tongues, that of men and that of angels, if I lack love , I am a resonating metal, a clanging cymbal. Even if I had the gift of prophecy, the knowledge of all mysteries and all knowledge, when I had the most complete faith, that which moves mountains, if I lack love, I am nothing . If I distribute all my goods to the hungry, when I deliver my body to the flames, if I lack love, I gain nothing. Love takes patience, love is of service, it does not jealous, it does not show off, it does not get puffed up with pride, it does nothing ugly, it does not seek its own interest, it does not does not irritate, he does not harbor grudges, he does not rejoice in injustice, but he finds his joy in the truth. He excuses everything, he believes everything, he hopes everything, he endures everything. Love never passes. The prophecies? They will be abolished. Languages? They will end. The knowledge? It will be abolished. [...] These three remain: faith, hope and love, but love is the greatest. (1Co 13, 1-13)
The hymn to love is a high point of New Testament writings. It is one of the most beautiful texts in world literature. It is often repeated during wedding ceremonies. Among the many charisms, the way of love is the charisma par excellence.
Freedom is one of the main themes addressed by Paul in this first letter to the Corinthians. He ardently defends Christian freedom against Judeo-Christians who want to impose the Law of Moses and Jewish customs on non-Jewish believers. He led this fight at the Council of Jerusalem and he will do it again in his epistle to the Galatians. In the Greek and Latin world, political and democratic freedom included the right to speak for all members of the citizens' assembly (the ekklesia) and the right to say everything (parrèsia), without fear of reprisals. Paul claims these rights for himself and for his churches.
Like the Stoics, Paul is a fierce defender of personal conscience. Regarding the consumption of meat offered to idols, he recalls that idols are nothing. We can therefore eat the meat offered to them (8, 4-6). But this freedom must be limited by fraternal charity towards those who risk being scandalized by this freedom (8, 7-13).
Paul does not intend to impose his own laws and he in no way claims to exercise spiritual tyranny: “It is not that we intend to rule your faith, we only want to contribute to your joy” (2 Cor. 1, 24). The Gospel is not a straitjacket. It is a law that is not imposed from the outside, like the Mosaic law, but it transforms from the inside.
According to Paul, Christians must change their view of Jesus as Paul himself did during his conversion in Damascus: Jesus must no longer be considered “cursed” because he was crucified, but as the “resurrected Lord”. The four gospels will mention the torture of the cross as the mode of execution of Jesus, but they will not do the theology of the cross. It is Paul who does it, and this for the first time in this epistle to the Corinthians (1 Cor 1, 18-31). This is his major contribution to Christian theology. The cross is a revelation. It tells us who God is for us. In the message of the cross, Paul discovers a God who surpasses all wisdom and all religion. It is there that he manifests his wisdom and his power, even where man sees only weakness and folly.
In this epistle, the Apostle's thoughts revolve around two poles: the Lord's Supper and fraternal love. The Eucharist is a source of nourishment for fraternal love. In Corinth, the feast had degenerated into a feast for some, while others did not have enough to eat.
Paul also answers questions received about the role of women during the celebrations. They asked to be assimilated to men in offices. They spoke there, and did not wear a veil. Paul advises the wearing of the veil, which corresponds to an almost universal habit in his time. We know that the prostitutes of Corinth went bareheaded. Christian women without veils thus risked being compared to the prostitutes of the port city. When it came to speaking in congregations, Paul followed Jewish custom in synagogues, which earned him the accusation of being a misogynist. It must be emphasized, however, that throughout his letters, women appear who campaign alongside him and play a leading role, a role that was forbidden to them in the synagogues and in Greek and Roman institutions. They have important positions in the Churches. In Corinth itself one is minister or deaconess of a community. Among the Christians cited by Paul in his epistles are nine women to whom, on several occasions, he expresses esteem and affection.
Paul devotes the last chapter of this epistle to faith in the resurrection (1 Cor 15). The letter began with “the language of the Cross” and ended with the proclamation of the resurrection of Christ and the announcement of the resurrection of believers. It is therefore framed by the Paschal mystery.
That's a lot of topics for one letter. The First Epistle to the Corinthians is long, extremely dense and surprisingly varied, but it is extraordinarily rich and allows us to take a look at the life of the early Church. However, it seems that it did not have the expected effect. During the summer of 54, when Timothy returned to Ephesus, he reported that he had been very poorly received in Corinth. Anyone other than Paul would have been discouraged. He holds on. He never gives up. The crisis will rebound and give rise to other interventions, to other visits from Paul and Titus, to other letters.