Welcome!

By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our community.

SignUp Now!
  • Welcome to Talk Jesus Christian Forums

    Celebrating 20 Years!

    A bible based, Jesus Christ centered community.

    Register Log In

There is no trinity in John 1:1

This plural is not the trinity or the "majestic plural", it's neither of those. It refers to God AND His divine council. One prominent example is Ps. 82:1 - “God stands in the congregation of the mighty; He judges among the gods." In the original Hebrew, both God and gods in this verse are elohim with no difference, believe it or not. God doesn't stand in the midst of himself or judge himself, he's judging the corrupt heavenly hosts in this divine council.
The Trinity doctrine is a man made doctrine. The men who came up with it said there are three coequal, coeternal, persons who are one God. That's what Trinitarians mean when the speak of a Trinity. It seems you're defining that differently. But the vast majority describe it the way I stated. I think it's pretty clear if we look at the Scriptures that that's not the case.
 
Hi @BUTCH,

When I read this thread, I find a children's hymn come into my mind:-

'I am not skilled to understand,
what God has willed,
what God has planned,
I only know at His right hand,
stands One Who is my Saviour'.

I yield my finite mind to His infinite one, and praise Him, that He knows all things, and that one day I shall know, even as I am now known.

Praise His Holy Name!

In Christ Jesus
Chris
 
'For by Him were all things created,
that are in heaven, and that are in earth,
visible and invisible,
whether they be thrones, or dominions, or principalities, or powers:
all things were created by Him, and for Him:
And He is before all things,
and by Him all things consist.
And He is the head of the body, the church:
Who is the beginning, the firstborn from the dead;
that in all things He might have the preeminence.
For it pleased the Father that in Him should all fulness dwell;
And, having made peace through the blood of His cross,
by Him to reconcile all things unto Himself;
by Him, I say, whether they be things in earth, or things in heaven.'
(Col 1:16-20)

Praise God!

:love:
You conveniently left out vs 15 where Jesus is identified as a created being. God had no beginning.
 
The Trinity doctrine is a man made doctrine. The men who came up with it said there are three coequal, coeternal, persons who are one God. That's what Trinitarians mean when the speak of a Trinity. It seems you're defining that differently. But the vast majority describe it the way I stated. I think it's pretty clear if we look at the Scriptures that that's not the case.
Hi Chris, I often find that many ascribe this doctrine to the the unknowable. In many other things I can agree with that. For instance, how does God raise the dead? I don't know. However, I find the opposite with this doctrine. I don't find the infinite mind of God. I find the finite mind of man. Man reading something he hasn't quite grasped and instead of looking to reason he has accepted that which is illogical and absurd. The passages of Scriputre that refer to Jesus as God can easily be understood in a manner that is quite logical. That being the case why would we look to that which is illogical? I think it's pretty clear that those who wrote the Athanasian Creed didn't have a good grasp of Scripture. It's like those who wrote the Westmisbter Confession, who said God is the author of all things yet He is not the author of sin. That is an illogical statement. Sin is a thing. If God was the author of all things then the statement requires that sin is included. This statement is based in an erroneous theology. But, rather than say, hey our theology is illogical they simply dismissed it and calimed it some mystery beyond our comprehension. No it's not. It's illogical and wrong. It's the same with the Trinity doctrine. It's not beyond our comprehension, it's just illogical and wrong. Just like those who wrote the Westminster Confession, people refuse to look at their theology and say it's wrong.
 
The Trinity doctrine is a man made doctrine. The men who came up with it said there are three coequal, coeternal, persons who are one God. That's what Trinitarians mean when the speak of a Trinity. It seems you're defining that differently. But the vast majority describe it the way I stated. I think it's pretty clear if we look at the Scriptures that that's not the case.
You know, at the end there's gonna be a counterfeit trinity of Dragon, the Sea Beast and the Earth Beast, right? Call it whatever you want, that's a counterfeit of the original, and it's coming. Satan only counterfeits what's originally created by God and proven to be working. If this was just a "man made doctrine", Satan wouldn't counterfeit it, and it wouldn't have been illustrated to John in Revelation.
 
I
You know, at the end there's gonna be a counterfeit trinity of Dragon, the Sea Beast and the Earth Beast, right? Call it whatever you want, that's a counterfeit of the original, and it's coming. Satan only counterfeits what's originally created by God and proven to be working. If this was just a "man made doctrine", Satan wouldn't counterfeit it, and it wouldn't have been illustrated to John in Revelation.
I'm not aware of anything in Scripture that says Satan is counterfeiting anything. I think theology is too much opinion and not enough Scripture.
 
2Co 11:14 But I am not surprised! Even Satan disguises himself as an angel of light.
2Co 11:15 So it is no wonder that his servants also disguise themselves as servants of righteousness. In the end they will get the punishment their wicked deeds deserve.
 
Gen 1:26 And God said, Let us make man in our image, after our likeness:…..

who is the “us”, and who is the “our” image God would make man into?
Remember angels can not create anything.
 
This plural is not the trinity or the "majestic plural", it's neither of those. It refers to God AND His divine council. One prominent example is Ps. 82:1 - “God stands in the congregation of the mighty; He judges among the gods." In the original Hebrew, both God and gods in this verse are elohim with no difference, believe it or not. God doesn't stand in the midst of himself or judge himself, he's judging the corrupt heavenly hosts in this divine council.
So...Let's see now...You do not believe in the trinity....you do not believe in the rapture.....What else do you not believe? Do you believe Jesus is God at all?
 
You conveniently left out vs 15 where Jesus is identified as a created being. God had no beginning.
How does vs 15 say that Jesus is created? It says no such thing. It says Jesus is the visible image of the invisible Father.....When you look at Jesus you are seeing the Father
 
2Pe 3:15 And remember, our Lord’s patience gives people time to be saved. This is what our beloved brother Paul also wrote to you with the wisdom God gave him—
2Pe 3:16 speaking of these things in all of his letters. Some of his comments are hard to understand, and those who are ignorant and unstable have twisted his letters to mean something quite different, just as they do with other parts of Scripture. And this will result in their destruction. (NLT)
 
So...Let's see now...You do not believe in the trinity....you do not believe in the rapture.....What else do you not believe? Do you believe Jesus is God at all?
I do believe in Trinity, I don’t believe in “three gods in one”; I do believe in rapture, I don’t believe in alien abduction.
 
I

I'm not aware of anything in Scripture that says Satan is counterfeiting anything. I think theology is too much opinion and not enough Scripture.
“I will be LIKE the most high;” (Is. 14:14)

“Many false prophets will rise up and deceive many;” (Matt. 24:11)

“Then I saw another beast coming out of the earth, and he had two horns LIKE a lamb and spoke like a dragon;” (Rev. 13:11)

In fact, the word “blasphemy” means somebody claims to be God, so wherever the Antichrist entity “blasphemes” God, that’s Satan counterfeiting God. Just because you don’t know doesn’t mean it’s not there.
 
“I will be LIKE the most high;” (Is. 14:14)

“Many false prophets will rise up and deceive many;” (Matt. 24:11)

“Then I saw another beast coming out of the earth, and he had two horns LIKE a lamb and spoke like a dragon;” (Rev. 13:11)

In fact, the word “blasphemy” means somebody claims to be God, so wherever the Antichrist entity “blasphemes” God, that’s Satan counterfeiting God. Just because you don’t know doesn’t mean it’s not there.
I didn't say, I don't know. I said I don't see it in Scripture. Satan, the Beast and prophets, plural, is more that three isn't it?
 
I didn't say, I don't know. I said I don't see it in Scripture. Satan, the Beast and prophets, plural, is more that three isn't it?
Those "many" false prophets will rally under the leadership of only one, the great harlot of Babylon. It is written in the Scripture that she's the "mother of all harlots", and yet she's only counted as one. And in case you missed it, that's a counterfeit of the woman of apocalypse and her offsprings in ch. 12.
 
Those "many" false prophets will rally under the leadership of only one, the great harlot of Babylon. It is written in the Scripture that she has many offsprings, and yet she's only counted as one.
Many are counted as one. That seems to have a recurring theme in this thread.

Again, if only there was as much Scripture as there is opinion in theology today Christians might agree on some things
 
Many are counted as one. That seems to have a recurring theme in this thread.

Again, if only there was as much Scripture as there is opinion in theology today Christians might agree on some things
Great, show me where I said "many are counted as one" verbatim. I only said "she (the great harlot of Babylon)" is counted as one, I've never said "many" are counted as one. Besides, it's neither an "opinion" nor a "theology" that many false religions are being incorporated into the climate change cult, that's what's happening in the real world. If you truly believe that the Scripture is alive and active, you better pay attention.
 
Great, show me where I said "many are counted as one" verbatim. I only said "she (the great harlot of Babylon)" is counted as one, I've never said "many" are counted as one. Besides, it's neither an "opinion" nor a "theology" that many false religions are being incorporated into the climate change cult, that's what's happening in the real world. If you truly believe that the Scripture is alive and active, you better pay attention.
You said,

"Those "many" false prophets will rally under the leadership of only one, the great harlot of Babylon"

I'm not sure how you went from a counterfeit trinity to climate change.

By the way, there is no trinity. It's only the Fsther and the Son. Jesus tells us that the Spirit "is" the Father.
 
You said,

"Those "many" false prophets will rally under the leadership of only one, the great harlot of Babylon"

I'm not sure how you went from a counterfeit trinity to climate change.

By the way, there is no trinity. It's only the Fsther and the Son. Jesus tells us that the Spirit "is" the Father.
I repeat, I've never said "many are counted as one" verbatim, don't put your words into my mouth.

Climate change is a false religion, that's what is being shoved in your face by those "many" false prophets. You disregard it as "opinion" and "theology", I showed you it's not, it's happening in the real world.

Also, for the record, I oppose the traditional "three in one" trinity doctrine as much as you do, I'm not your enemy. There's only one God, the Son and the Spirit are the intermediary between men and God.
 
By the way, there is no trinity. It's only the Fsther and the Son. Jesus tells us that the Spirit "is" the Father.
Sir, what doesn't exist is the DOCTRINE of "three co-equal persons", which always falls into either of two heresies: tritheism - three gods, or modalism - three forms of one god. Neither of these is taught in the Scripture, and that's where it falls apart.
 
Back
Top